Saturday, 31 August 2013

Website Evaluation








BBC Learning English

The target group for this site would be intermediate to advanced ESL students who had some understanding of British culture. There are ways of using this site for less advanced ESL student groups but I was concentrating on listening exercises for advanced English speakers.

The website has many of the characteristics of a large media organisation’s website and has topical, authentic and current information on issues in the news. I used the article on the sentencing of whistle-blower Bradley Manning as a focus of my attention. Each article includes a printed and written text version. One neat idea was the inclusion of a special audio section on the pronunciation and definition of unusual vocabulary and expressions from the article eg “burst into tears” and “eligible for parole”.

A teaching idea would be to have students present a short report in a newsreader style to the class recounting the facts of a recent news story after they had read and listened to the article on BBC learning English.



  

5minuteegligh

This site is designed for intermediate ESL students who want to do a quick exercise to practice their English. Once again focussing on listening skills, the site offered an array of listening tasks. It is also a meta-site with gateways and links to numerous other similar sites included at the end of the listening section. I particularly like the daily word (with definition) which was “pithy” when I visited. This was pertinent as the site is pithy, in that it gets down to core learning quickly and effectively. The site also contains some long winded articles on theory of language learning which might be useful to very advanced students but seemed a little misplaced on a “5 minute English” site.

When looking for a teaching idea the lesson Dogs, Dogs, Dogs represents an excellent listening activity as well as having the bonus of explaining some unusual English idiom like “To be in the doghouse”.





EnglishClub

The name of this site is EnglishClub. It appears to be a commercially run site which promoted advertising from associated English learning and language courses. There is a large number of advertisements through the site and this feature detracts from an otherwise impressive set up. The target group for this site is broad and it would offer teaching opportunities for beginners through to advanced ESL students.

The listening section of this site is comprehensive and includes exercises based on dictation, listening to the radio, podcasts, this week in history MP3 with quiz, poetry reading, videos and songs. There is also a section that contains links to other websites with relevant listening practice exercises. The samples I tried were authentic and useful in their presentation and offered realistic use of vocabulary and accents.

Two teaching ideas that were imaginative involved the use of poetry and the airline safety announcements listening tasks. Using poetry can help ESL understand the emotion or underlying tone in a short piece of written English. Students could retell the poem including some emotion or feeling to increase the level of interest for the others listening. Secondly I would use the audio presentation of airline announcements as a lesson starter for ESL students. Role playing the cabin crew delivering the safety announcements with a few simple props (mask and lifejacket) could help transfer the learning acquired from listening to the audio to a presentation to class members.





ESLgold

The name of this site is eslgold.com. It also appears to be a commercial site that promotes advertising of language learning services and products as well as general advertising. The ads seemed a little less intrusive on this site than some of the other commercial sites. This site specifically identified a variety of levels of study for students so they could pick an appropriate place to start using the listening exercises provided.

I particularly liked the set-up of the listening lesson which featured a pre-viewing section, a vocabulary and expressions section, then a short video and a multiple choice quiz to finish. Previewing an area to focus students is important in maximising the value of the lesson provided. The site provided self-contained lessons that a teacher could look at to establish the appropriate level for their students and then run them as they are set out on the website. This would greatly reduce preparation time as the teacher would simply have to complete the lesson themselves to be ready to teach.




Splash – ABC Early Primary English.

This government owned media website was specifically designed to give Early Primary teachers ideas when taking English lessons. It could easily be adapted for use with intermediate ESL students as a listening lesson resource. Obviously it has a great application for younger students of ESL.

The site is easy to navigate and free of advertisements.
In the exercise called “A song about Koalas” the student is required to read information about koalas before listening to audio about koalas. This is followed up by a short writing and drawing exercise (ESL could label body parts). This lesson is ready to go and requires a short preparation time for teachers who are familiar with the site.


BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS

Cunningsworth, A 1995, Choosing your coursebook, Heinemann English Language Teaching, Oxford.

Dudeney, G & Hockly, N 2007, How to teach English with technology, Pearson Educational Ltd, Harlow UK.

Tanner, R & Green, C 1998, Tasks for Teacher Education: A Reflective Approach, Addison Wesley Publishing Company, Boston.

Thurlow, S & O’Sullivan K 2011, Focusing on IELTS: Listening and Speaking (2nd Ed.), MacMillan Education Australia, South Yarra.

WEBSITES

ABC Early Primary English (Splash) available from 
[Viewed 28 August 2013]

BBC Learning English available from  
[Viewed 27 August 2013]

EnglishClub available from  
[Viewed 28 August 2013]

ESLgold available from  
[Viewed 28 August 2013]

5minuteegligh.com available from  
[Viewed 27 August 2013]


Software Evaluation

EyeSpeak English Premium Edition (Demo Version downloaded 26/08/2013)

The EyeSpeak English software was designed to help ESL students improve their communication skills and particularly their listening and speaking skills.  I was particularly interested in its approach to teaching speaking skills for advanced ESL students. The demo version used for this review was sourced through the website:  
The blurb on this website indicated that the software was targeted at students who were interested in hearing an Australian accent. In contrast the statement on the front page of the software said “EyeSpeak – The fastest way to learn how to sound American or British”. The software was developed by a New Zealand company and the full version of the software allows for greater cultural context specification, which would assist students to specify the type of learning experience they were wanting by picking a particular accent.
The major selling point of this software package involves their approach to speech analysis. They claim that “Our unique speech analysis technology will compare your speech to your teacher, and let you know what you may need to improve on. Our feedback system is the only software that provides an animated personal tongue diagram, showing you exactly what you need to do to make the right sound”. This anatomical approach to speaking was something I haven’t seen on other packages I looked at. It allowed students to view pictures of cross-sections of the mouth while making specific sounds and this seemed to me to be highly beneficial in making real change in approach to pronunciation and speech production. This process can be tailored to individual student needs by asking for the home language of the student so that specific pronunciation issues are emphasised based on that home language.
With over 6,000 exercises the software covers a great variety of different language scenarios. Their claims to having a balanced curriculum were predicated on including listening, vocabulary and sound exercises. The exercises were more of a collection rather than a dynamic and clearly progressive curriculum. This software would be excellent to assist advanced ESL students experiment with pronunciation and accent issues so they could gain confidence in the way they speak English.
Costing $165AUD for a 2 home use set it represents a medium cost software option = 4/5.



Course Book Evaluation


Focussing on IELTS: listening and speaking skills (2nd ed.)


Focussing on IELTS: listening and speaking skills (2nd ed.) was produced to give students attempting the IELTS exam a contemporary and comprehensive resource in the form of a 206 pp. course book and 4 audio CDs.

The methodology employed by the first section of this resource includes listening to conversations on CDs and answering matching, short answer and multiple-choice questions. It also includes various strategies to assist students to enhance and improve their listening skills. These suggestions include developing an independent study program and designing a listening checklist. The speaking section covers a broad range of topics and identifies specific approaches to grammar, pronunciation, vocabulary and fluency. The resource is tailored for independent use or as a class textbook. It claims to be useful for both academic and general application. I found it suitable for independent study but wondered about my role as the teacher in the listening section while teaching with such a self-contained text. Both sections conclude with a comprehensive practice test. The book also includes a transcripts section and answer key section.

The appearance of this resource is significantly improved on the 1st edition. The front cover is bright and clear. Unfortunately the black and white photos in this edition are a bit dull and ambiguous but the diagrams and drawing are excellent and they certainly add to its usability. The CDs use Australian and other voices in believable conversation situations. The intonations and pauses in the speech used are authentic. This format gives the resource a realism which makes me more confident that it will assist students preparing to do an IELTS test.

A clear contents section, layout, and “how to use page” make the book teacher friendly while reducing preparation time because of its comprehensiveness. The CDs offer a multimedia approach which effectively integrates with the strategies and exercises contained in the workbook.

New copies of the 2nd edition cost $49.99 and second hand older editions were selling for below $10. These are not unreasonable prices for this type of resource. Overall a comprehensive, interesting and affordable coursebook = 3.5/5.